4.25 In Theory

Rating: 2.5

When Data’s co-worker, Jenna, breaks up with her boyfriend, she turns to the android for friendship and more. Data, unsure of how to proceed, seeks advice from various crewmember friends, then uses that advice, along with his ‘book’ knowledge of love and relationships, to create a sometimes forced lover/partner. At first, it is enough for Jenna, but she soons realizes that Data can never love her, care for her, or need her, and she ends the relationship.

Meanwhile, the Enterprise is traveling into a dark matter nebula and strange, poltergeist-like occurrences are happening.

Comments

This episode was co-written by Joe Menosky and Ronald D. Moore, and directed by Patrick Stewart.

This is a deeper exploration of Data’s ability to love, although, once again, we find out that he is incapable. There is only a subtle hint, in the end, that if perhaps he could just allow himself to be himself, he could have had an unusual, but an effectionate, relationship with Jenna, such as he has with his cat Spot.

One nice touch about this episode is that the point is not to develop (and ruin) Data’s character by making him into a lover; it is to show that he is incapable. There is no character growth, which is original and not at all expected.

Nits

Data still has made little progress in knowing when phrases should not be taken literally. He responds to Guinan’s use of "Don’t look at me" by looking away from her. And when Jenna say, "Put those clothes down," he immediately drops them on the floor. These attempts at levity in the script seem contrived.

When Data is explaining why the anomalies are occurring, he uses ‘nebula’ twice in one sentence. The first time, he pronounces it normally, but the second time, he says what sounds like ‘nebular’. It just seemed strange that an android would be inconsistent.

Memorable Moments

•    None really, although Picard’s humorous line regarding advice interjects some needed levity.

Quotable Quotes

Data: Captain! I am seeking advice on how to-
Picard: Yes, I’ve heard, Data. And I will be delighted to offer any advice I can on understanding women. When I have some, I’ll let you know.

"Darling, you remain as aesthetically pleasing as the first day we met. I believe I am the most fortunate sentient in this section of the galaxy."
- Data, making love to Jenna

Data: Jenna, are we no longer a…couple?
Jenna: No, Data, we’re not.
Data: Then I will delete the appropriate program.